Pie Information and Pricing

These pies ain’t whimpy! They are deep and 9” wide to feed up to 12 folks! Our flakey, buttery pie dough is rolled and formed by hand, and all of our fillings are always made from scratch.  Place your special order for whole pies ($24.95 ea.) at least 7 days in advance or call us to see what we have in store.

pie

 

2tarts Pie Flavors

 

APPLE CINNAMON
Freshly peeled and cored Granny Smith apples spiced with cinnamon with a brown sugar butter streusel.

 

KEYLIME
No green dye here! Just rich, creamy lime goodness topped with whipped cream and fresh lime zest. Did I mention it comes with a perfectly sweet and salty shortbread crust?!

 

PEANUT BUTTER
Peanut butter mousse in a chocolate shortbread crust topped with chocolate ganache. Okay, seriously, hold the phone…This. Is. The. BEST!

 

PECAN
This southern favorite is made with locally sourced pecans tucked into our buttery pie crust!

 

STRAWBERRY RHUBARB
The tartness of rhubarb is a sweet strawberry’s best friend. Decorated with a beautiful woven lattice, this is one of the bakers’ favorites!

 

DELAINEY’S SILK CHOCOLATE PIE
Our head decorator came up with this new 2tarts staple. This silky, chocolate custard lays on a buttery oreo crust, and is topped with smooth whipped cream.

 

BUTTERMILK PIE

 

PUMPKIN
Seasonally available (October through December).  Creamy, but not too sweet brown sugar pumpkin pie filling in a buttery crust

 

STRAWBERRY CREAM PIE

 

SALTED HONEY PIE

 

CHICKEN POT PIES
Looking for an easy lunch during the holidays? Our creamy chicken pot pie is perfect for a comforting get together.

9”  chicken pot pie $39.94
5”  chicken pot pie $8.50

 

CHECK OUT OUR TART OPTIONS BY CLICKING HERE